Split Down the Middle

You were my first / But then there was you

You're old and familiar / But you're different and new

For you I worked hard / I'm just starting on you

You're one in a million / But then, you are, too    

You were untouchable / And you were unknown

Your heart was sold / And you were alone

I let you go  / And let you draw me in

But now you are free / And you are taken

So now you push closer / As you drift away

As I learn you all over / Relish every word you say

I can't fight for both

Can't choose between the two

I'm split down the middle

So what do I do?